In classical physics, at least on paper, it is possible to know both the exact position of a ball and its velocity. At the scale of the atom and below, quantum mechanics tells us that these two kinds of precision cannot be achieved simultaneously for all states. Heisenberg's uncertainty principle expresses this limit mathematically. The issue is not our confusion; it is simply the way the wave-particle structure works. Here, I explain the same idea without complicated equations.
What Does Uncertainty Mean, and What Does It Not Mean?
When we hear that position and velocity cannot be known precisely at the same time, our minds usually turn to measurement error. The camera is not powerful enough, the particle vibrates, or the light we shine on the particle to observe it disturbs the situation itself. These things matter in real experiments, but the uncertainty principle is about something else.
Whatever state a particle is in, its position and momentum cannot be specified simultaneously to any degree of precision we wish. If we repeat an experiment many times on particles in the same state, the results differ slightly. We denote the spread of these results for position by Δx and for momentum by . The smaller we make one, the larger the other becomes, and they cannot both reach zero.
Even if we imagine an experimenter who does not disturb the particle at all during measurement, this lower bound remains. This limit comes from the wave description of the particle itself, not from a defect in the instrument.
So the issue is not that we have not yet built better instruments. A quantum particle is described by a wave function[1], and the shape of this function constrains the simultaneous localization of the particle in position and momentum.
Why Is the Term "Uncertainty" Somewhat Misleading?
In English, the term uncertainty principle is more commonly used, while in German Unbestimmtheit, meaning indeterminacy or being undetermined. Some physicists prefer to use the term indeterminacy, meaning that the particle did not have a definite value in advance. This term is less likely to be confused with the experimenter's uncertainty.
For understanding this text, a simpler statement is sufficient. Position and momentum are two different aspects of a wave state. It is not possible to construct a state in which both aspects are simultaneously as sharply defined as desired.
Heisenberg and the Year 1927
Werner Heisenberg published a relation in 1927 that later became known by his name. He illustrated this idea using the gamma-ray microscope, which was a thought experiment[2]. The more precisely we want to observe a particle's position, the shorter the wavelength of light we must use, and such a photon carries greater momentum. The collision of this photon disturbs the particle's momentum even further. If the beam is softer, the position remains ambiguous.
Today, we know that the microscope argument is more of an illustration. Its deeper mathematical foundation goes back to the Fourier transform[3]. A function that is narrow in position becomes spread out in momentum. Nevertheless, this illustration remains a good starting point. Greater precision in one variable comes at the cost of the other.
The Formula Everyone Knows, in Simple Terms
For a particle moving along one direction, the uncertainty principle is written as follows:
What Does Each Symbol Mean?
indicates how spread out the particle's position is. Suppose we prepare many particles in exactly the same state and measure the position of each one. The results are not all identical; rather, they are distributed around a mean value. represents the magnitude of this spread. In statistics, this is called the standard deviation.
expresses the same concept for momentum. Momentum is the product of mass and velocity, that is, .
is pronounced 'h-bar.' It is Planck's constant divided by 2π. It is an extremely small number, approximately joule-seconds.
and are not errors associated with a single measurement. They represent the spread of results obtained from repeated measurements on identical states.
The formula does not say that Δx or Δp must individually be large. It states that their product cannot be less than . The more precisely we determine a particle's position, the more uncertain its momentum becomes, and vice versa. There is no state in which both and are zero.
A numerical example may help. An electron inside an atom is confined to a region of approximately 10⁻¹⁰ m, which is roughly the diameter of an atom. Therefore, is no greater than this value. Substituting this value into the formula gives a minimum momentum uncertainty of approximately . Since the electron's mass is extremely small, this momentum spread means that its velocity is spread over hundreds of kilometers per second. An electron confined within an atom cannot remain at rest and always possesses some kinetic energy.
The same point explains why an electron does not fall into the nucleus. If it moves closer to the nucleus, it becomes confined within a smaller region. becomes smaller and, consequently, and the kinetic energy become larger. This additional energy prevents the electron from getting too close to the nucleus.
The Relationship with EPR and Simultaneous Position and Momentum
This argument appears in the 1935 EPR paper. If the position and momentum of a distant particle can be predicted without interference, then those two quantities must be independent elements of reality. The quantum-mechanical response, in brief, is as follows: in the EPR thought experiment, Alice measures either position or momentum. She does not measure both simultaneously, with unlimited precision, on that same first particle. The uncertainty principle also does not allow a particle, in the classical sense, to have both a definite position and a definite momentum.
References
- W. Heisenberg, "Über den anschaulichen Inhalt der quantentheoretischen Kinematik und Mechanik", Zeitschrift für Physik 43, 172 (1927). English: "The Physical Content of Quantum Kinematics and Mechanics" (translations widely available).
- W. Heisenberg, "Uncertainty relations and quantum mechanics", in various collected works; see also modern pedagogical: American Journal of Physics review articles on Fourier derivation.
- N. Bohr, "The Quantum Postulate and the Recent Development of Atomic Theory", Nature 121, 580 (1928), complementarity context.
- R. P. Feynman, R. B. Leighton, M. Sands, The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol. III, Ch. 1–2 (wave-particle and uncertainty intuition).